Hello good reader!
The Truth is a Cave in the Black Mountains is a recent book by Neil Gaiman (if you don’t know who he is, shame on you) and I have to say, it’s one of the most perplexing books I’ve ever read, not solely for its content, but the ‘book’ (as in its physical-ness) as a whole.
It looks at first to be a picture book, a little children’s picture book. However on further inspection you;ll find that it is by no means a children’s story.
I won’t give anything big away about the story, because it is far too good to ruin with spoilers, but what starts off as an apparently simple story about a short man looking for gold quickly becomes something else. The story has a lot in and of itself, but there are things mentioned and alluded to that are never really explained, and now after finishing it, I still feel as though I missed something. I’m going to read it again, absolutely without a doubt I will read it again, and I recommend anyone read this book.
When I finished it I had a good long think about the art that is implicit story telling which, I think, is one of the hardest but most fulfilling ways to tell a story. When you only tell the reader what they need to know, but allude to so much more that they can figure out on their own, with enough determination and thought, of course.
The book has several lines in it that made me consider the nature of subjective truth, that is, how different things can be ‘true’ to different people, and how that changes, essentially, who they are. This is a big theme in the book, so I won’t divulge anymore in reference to it for fear of spoiling the story.
My two trains of thought about subjective truth and implicit story telling collided quite recently, and gave me one of the best creative boosts I’ve had in a long time.
A few days ago I thought I’d see how well I could implicitly tell a story. So I made an account on Reddit (something I once told myself I’d never do because of the filth that it has) and posted a very vague (but well thought out on my part) ‘creepy’ story to r/nosleep (in all honesty I just didn’t know where else to put it. I guess you could say it’s dark fantasy, so it seemed to fit). I’d been working on parts of this story for a long time, but there was one part I couldn’t work out. It was like a real bugger of a mathematics problem that I just couldn’t solve, so I decided to just cut it from the story.
So I wrote this cut-down version of the story, posted it, and came back in an hour to find it had been very well received and there were a decent amount of comments on it with people trying to explain different parts of the story and wanting more information on the more vague details, which was just what I wanted. One of the comments I didn’t understand, so I asked the user for some clarification on what he meant by his question, lo and behold the theory he had about the story was the missing piece that I had failed to figure out by myself.
After thanking this guy/gal profusely I had a brain explosion about how the story wouldn’t be as developed as it is now without implicit story telling, and subjective truth. To this user, there was no other explanation to the gap in my story, but it’s not at all what I was thinking when I wrote it, to me it wasn’t ‘true’ and to him, it was.
The reception of my story and the speculation about it made me the happiest I’ve felt in a long time. I’ve always been very uncomfortable about sharing my work with other people (hence why I use an anonymous blog) and this gave me the boost in confidence I needed to start getting more stuff out there, I still feel ecstatic.
So thanks to this legendary individual, something I’ve been working on for two years is about to start rolling through. Thanks to implicit story telling, thanks to subjective truth.
Once I have a bit more of my story written, I’ll be posting it here. But until then.
That is All.